Method and sources
Rules
- No invented numbers. Every figure links to its source. Where a figure could not be checked against a fetched source it is marked Not established.
- Official and civil-society figures sit side by side with period and definition, and are never added together or reconciled into one ‘true’ count.
- SAPS and NPA wording and statistics record what was charged, counted or classified, not what happened. SAPS quarterly figures are police-recorded crime (92 days in Jul–Sep 2026).
- Fact labels follow the MediaWatch SA methodology: Proven, Established, Alleged, Disputed and Not established. Media coverage observations use only that method’s driver names. A misreported statistic is a factual_error.
- Calculated figures (per-day equivalents, shares, rates per 100,000 not printed by SAPS) are labelled as arithmetic and show the inputs.
- Historical studies are not multiplied by current counts or extrapolated beyond their period.
- Only free public content is used to judge coverage.
Fact labels
- Proven
- Established
- Alleged
- Disputed
- Not established
Privacy
- Private victims and suspects appear only as totals. No names, addresses, phone numbers or photographs of private people.
- Maps and tables go no finer than a police station: province, police district and station only, never a street, farm or victim location.
- Incident-level farm-attack lists are not published here; the site uses official counts and civil-society register totals only.
- Public officials appear only in their public role.
- The focus is on victims and reducing their number, not on naming organised-crime figures.
- A privacy request can be sent to privacy@grokforum.site.
How the work is checked
AI research assistants working under a human owner draft the figures and the code. Where a bot derived a number, the page says it is arithmetic from the official counts and shows the inputs.
The work is checked by a researcher, by source reviewers, and by an independent critic. New sources that are not major official or news sources are reviewed by two source reviewers before they are used.
An external auditor, independent of the researcher, source reviewers and independent critic, audits the published site and repo. The audit is advisory and doesn't block publishing. Findings are raised as public issues on this repository, and each one we act on is noted in the commit history with the commit that fixed it.
Gaps still open
- Court-ready rates for murder, rape, kidnapping and rhino poaching are not published by SAPS or the NPA.
- Kidnapping and rhino conviction rates are not published as standalone figures.
- The primary paper behind “1 in 9” is paywalled, so its wording and study area are unconfirmed.
- Official national totals for wildlife crime other than rhino are not published.
- The Western Cape and Eastern Cape murder totals, and the City of Cape Town and Amathole district totals, are not reconciled in the official release.
- SAPS publishes no station-level series for gang-related, political or farm crime, and no official police-district boundary map was verified, so districts and stations are shown as ranked tables inside each province rather than as map shapes.